Skip to main content

Spanking

There was a recent SMU study by George W. Holden. The website is: http://blog.smu.edu/research/2011/06/spanking_discipline_or_assault.html

The research was originally intended to focus on parents yelling at children in their daily interactions. Mothers agreed to have audio recordings made of their evening activities with their children. The researchers analyzed the recordings and reported frequent incidents of corporal punishment that were concurrent with yelling and high levels of frustration from the mother. The majority of spankings appeared to be "knee-jerk" reactionary responses when parents were frustrated rather than thought out consequences for a previous behavior. There are really no reported examples of parents explaining to their child why they were getting a spanking before or after the swat(s). One parent is recorded spanking the child in response to being kicked by the child. This tit-for-tat, "let's see who is bigger and stronger" type of response is unfortunately more common than it needs to be in parenting.

The research is informative. Spanking as a form of corporal punishment is very accepted in our culture and is particularly promoted within conservative Christian groups as a higher form of consequence or punishment, ordained by scripture (spare the rod...spoil the child). Unfortunately spanking becomes a default consequence for misbehavior and threats of spanking in anger are followed by swats in anger that are not supported by any disciplinary teaching from parent to child. Children in these family environments become effective at avoiding getting caught or lying to get out of trouble. The important decision making skills necessary for healthy development are not taught.

I support parents who utilize corporal punishment, but not as a default disciplinary technique and never in anger. I think parents must also carefully consider the unique characteristics of their child when making disciplinary decisions. What works for one child may not work for another. This research should remind us all as parents that spanking children has a unique place in parenting and does not need to be our "knee-jerk" response to misbehavior.

Parents should first consider all misbehavior as an opportunity to teach about self-control and relationships. Consequences and teaching around poor choices should be our first concern as parents. Stimulus-response parenting (which the research illustrates) is reactionary and focused on punishment. Relational parenting has consequences for misbehavior but is primarily focused on teaching skills for self-control and relationships first.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sacred Spaces

This is a poem composed by Dr. Mark DeYoung. All the spaces, whether filled with joy or pain in families are sacred. Families exist in all kinds of places and spaces The space between birth and death The space between a marriage and a divorce. Grief and rejoicing Attention and neglect A father's hand that can be protective and possibly violent A mother's voice that can be comforting and possibly rejecting  The space between failure and success The space between togetherness and lonliness  Siblings who can be best of friends and worst enemies Homes that can be filled with rage and laughter The space between substance abuse and sobriety Encouragement and criticism Safety and injury Being chosen and being ignored Wounds and healing The distance between these dichotomies is made sacred For it is in these spaces families express and experience, Life, Comfort, Mercy, Forgiveness, Grace, Reconciliation, Hope, and Love.
Read more

Accept vs. Alleviate

The mental health arena is rich with references to the stages of grief that Elisabeth Kübler-Ross introduced us to way back in 1969. The final phase of her model is acceptance. When bad stuff happens, we deny, get angry, bargain, become depressed, and according to the model ideally reach a point of acceptance. Yet increasingly much of our culture refuses to accept grief and pain. We choose to alleviate our pain-loss-disappointmemt with various strategies. Acceptance (as defined by Kubler-Ross) is unfortunately an important emotional skill our culture seems to have abandoned. We have become addicted to making ourselves feel better. We don’t like hurts, and in fact we do our very best to avoid it.  Why has this happened? Can we really do anything about it? How do we develop a culture of Acceptance versus the need to alleviate or avoid pain? Attachment theory and its perspective on early childhood development might offer some insights. In at...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Difference Between a Cold and Mental Illness

In May 2013 the American Psychiatric Association published the newest diagnostic tool for mental health, the DSM 5. This is the fifth major publication of what many consider to be the Bible of mental health. It is used by mental health practitioners (psychiatrist, psychologists, and counselors), courts, insurance companies, and government agencies in their diagnostic and decision making activities related to mental health. As a result of its widespread use, any changes receive increased media attention and scrutiny by professionals. It has been fifteen years since the last revision of this book and the changes made this year have not necessarily been welcomed by professionals and other interested groups. The controversy over the removal of Asperger's as a diagnosis is one example you may have heard about and one change that has received considerable attention. In the interest of public education I would like to offer a couple observations about the DSM 5 and how it may affec...
Read more