Skip to main content

Empathy as a Disciplinary Tool

Research has suggested that a building block for healthy development is a child’s ability to recognize the “You-I” distinction. I am Me and You are You. You might have different feelings than Me. You might think differently than Me. I might be interested in something different than You and I might feel differently than You.

Developing this important social skill, begins in infancy and continues throughout childhood. The basic building block for developing the skill is parental empathy. When a parent acknowledges a child’s thoughts, and feelings it helps the child draw the distinction between self and others.

Unfortunately, many times in disciplinary situations, because of the intensity of the moment, or the necessity to deal with the situation quickly, acknowledging a child’s feelings becomes a challenge. I would suggest that a primary disciplinary tool is to begin discipline by acknowledging a child child’s feelings.

“I understand that broccoli is not your favorite food and it tastes yucky to you.”

“I bet it hurt when your friend hit you.”

“It sounds like you were mad when you took your toy back from your friend.”

“Taking the trash out when it is cold is not your favorite thing.”

Last month we talked about listening to our children. Listening gives us the starting point from which to make empathic statements. Many child development experts have suggested that an empathic statement from a parent can sometimes be all that is needed to diffuse a potential temper tantrum.

Another helpful addition to your empathic acknowledgement of your child’s feelings is to share your personal feelings with your child. In quieter moments as you discuss a particular event, it can be helpful for your child to hear how their actions affected you.

“It made me sad when you yelled at me.”

“It really hurt when you slapped my arm.”

“I sometimes worry when you spend so much time alone; I wonder what you are thinking about.”

I cannot emphasize enough the importance that when you make these statements to your children that must be done with a calm, even tone and without sarcasm. Also, be aware that these empathic statements need to be delivered prior to a meltdown. Once a child is in a temper tantrum, they will fall on deaf ears. You will need to wait until the temper tantrum has subsided to discuss the feelings.I hope these ideas can open up new understandings in your relationship with your children.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sacred Spaces

This is a poem composed by Dr. Mark DeYoung. All the spaces, whether filled with joy or pain in families are sacred. Families exist in all kinds of places and spaces The space between birth and death The space between a marriage and a divorce. Grief and rejoicing Attention and neglect A father's hand that can be protective and possibly violent A mother's voice that can be comforting and possibly rejecting  The space between failure and success The space between togetherness and lonliness  Siblings who can be best of friends and worst enemies Homes that can be filled with rage and laughter The space between substance abuse and sobriety Encouragement and criticism Safety and injury Being chosen and being ignored Wounds and healing The distance between these dichotomies is made sacred For it is in these spaces families express and experience, Life, Comfort, Mercy, Forgiveness, Grace, Reconciliation, Hope, and Love.

Attachment and Wild Things

As a young child I remember reading "Where the Wild Things Are" and I don't feel like I related to Max. I was a pretty easy going, compliant kid and can't remember being sent to my room without my supper. Now as a father and family therapist I have come to see that Maurice Sendak had an amazing insight into the world of children and their experiences. Max is a young boy in the developmental middle of great emotional growth and his defiance and tantrums one night lead him to episode after episode of chaos. Most parents of young children can relate to witnessing similar episodes, and we know that a young child's immature emotional brains can easily become overwhelmed, resulting in impulsivity, defiance, and tantrums. Max's final explosion towards his mother results in being sent to his room and his adventure with the Wild Things. His time with the Wild Things serves as a metaphor for every child's attempts to tame the monstrous and overwhelming feelings t

Authority Problems

We have an authority problem. Recent news overwhelms with incidents of blatant disrespect for authority figures. Here are a few samples. Tom Brady appeals his suspension for cheating and wins reprieve from a four game suspension. Our culture’s worship of sports heroes has sunk to a new low when blatant cheating is disregarded and a Superbowl champion is allowed to get away without penalty. I think Pete Rose is probably pretty upset. Two high school football athletes, apparently angry over a call made by a referee assaults the referee during the game. The extent to which adults were involved is still unclear. Four police officers are violently gunned down in assassination attacks in the past few weeks for no reason other than wearing the uniform. A fourteen year old student brings an engineering project to school that looks suspiciously dangerous and refuses to put it away when asked by two teachers. Authorities' response to his choices are labeled as racism and